Almost All of the Wolves on One Alaskan Island Were Killed by Trappers This Winter

Conservation groups are calling on the U.S. Forest Service (FS) to take urgent action in order to protect a vulnerable population of wolves living on Prince of Wales Island in Alaska's Tongass National Forest after it emerged that 97 percent of the known population, given the most recent estimate, was legally killed during the 2019-2020 trapping season.

In early March, the Alaska Department of Fish and Game (ADF&G) announced that trappers had killed 165 Alexander Archipelago wolves—which some consider to be a subspecies of the northwestern wolf—living on the island and surrounding islands. The last estimate of the population was 170, as of fall 2018.

Non-profits Defenders of Wildlife, the Center for Biological Diversity, and the Southeast Alaska Conservation Council say that this is a record number of killings. Furthermore, the figure does not include any potential illegal killings, which have not been uncommon in the past.

In light of the news, the conservation groups have written a letter to the FS urging the agency to implement conservation measures outlined in a wolf management program in 2017. This program, known as the Wolf Habitat Management Program, was developed by the FS and ADF&G specifically in response to concerns about the survival of the population.

"This is a shocking number of wolves to have been taken, and once again there has to be concern for the viability of wolves on Prince of Wales Island," Nicole Whittington-Evans, Alaska program director for Defenders of Wildlife, said in a statement provided to Newsweek. "The U.S. Forest Service must engage with the state on wolf management decisions to ensure that this imperiled wolf population and its forest habitat will remain healthy for future generations."

Conservation groups say that the wolves on Prince of Wales Island are facing several threats, including unsustainable trapping and hunting, as well as the destruction of their forest home through industrial logging and road construction. Between 1994 and 2014 the population of these wolves decreased from an estimated mean of 336 to 89.

Subsequently, lower quotas were introduced, allowing around 20 percent of the population or lower to be trapped, leading to an increase in wolf numbers. By the fall of 2017, the estimated population had risen to 225 wolves, although this dropped again to 170 by the fall of 2018.

This is the last estimate of the population that officials have because determining the figure takes several months. For example, the fall 2019 estimate will not be ready until August or September this year, when it is likely to be significantly lower following the killings.

Despite the apparent success of the lower wolf-trapping quotas in enabling the wolf population to bounce back, the ADF&G lifted all harvest limits for the two-month trapping season that ended on January 15, 2020 in a controversial move. If the quota had been in place, trappers would only have been allowed to legally kill 34 wolves during the past season, the conservation groups say.

"The unprecedented killing of these imperiled wolves is an appalling and completely predictable result of reckless mismanagement," Shaye Wolf, a scientist at the Center for Biological Diversity, said in a statement. "It's difficult to see how state and federal officials can allow hunting and trapping next season without completely wiping out these wolves. They have a duty to protect these beautiful animals from extinction."

Meredith Trainor, executive director for the Southeast Alaska Conservation Council, also criticized state and federal authorities for allowing so many wolves to be killed in the 2019-2020 trapping season.

"While wolf management has always been a controversial issue in Southeast Alaska, it simply belies common sense for the Alaska Department of Fish and Game to allow legal trapping of 97 percent of any game population," said in a statement. "With this letter we're calling on the U.S. Forest Service to take a larger role in, at a minimum, ensuring sustainably managed wolf populations on Prince of Wales Island by partnering with the Alaska Department of Fish and Game to immediately return to the quota system."

The conservation groups are urging the FS to work with the ADF&G "to ensure a sustainable hunting and trapping level in 2020-21 and beyond, including a return to the quota system."

"It is incumbent upon the Forest Service to intervene and implement the Wolf Habitat Management Program, as mandated by the Tongass Forest Plan," the conservation groups wrote in their letter. "The Tongass Forest Plan requires the Forest Service to 'assist in maintaining long-term sustainable wolf populations.' More specifically, where there is a 'mortality concern' for wolves, the agency must 'develop and implement a Wolf Habitat Management Program in conjunction with ADF&G.'"

"Close collaboration and alignment are again necessary to ensure that the agencies' mutual interest in maintaining sustainable wildlife populations is achieved in the Tongass National Forest for wolves on Prince of Wales and nearby islands," the conservation groups wrote.

The Wolf Habitat Management Program devised by the FS and ADF&G includes measures such as:

• Altering quotas on a yearly basis to ensure wolf population and harvest sustainability.
• Monitoring the wolf population to help evaluate the effectiveness of the program.
• Increasing enforcement capabilities.

Located in the southeast of Alaska, Tongass is the largest national forest in the U.S.—covering an area of around 16.7 million acres. In fact, it is one of the largest intact temperate forests in the world, and is often described as the "crown jewel" in the U.S. National Forest system. And the wolves are in important part of this ecosystem.

"Alexander Archipelago wolves reflect the health of the forest—a healthy, intact ecosystem equals a healthy wolf and sitka deer population," Patrick Lavin, Alaska Policy Advisor for Defenders of Wildlife, told Newsweek.

However, officials note that the trapping of wolves may need to continue on the island. Many southeast Alaskans are dependent upon subsistence, with trappers and hunters often relying on deer meat to live. In Alaska, a valid state hunting and/or trapping license is required for hunters to kill wolves, which are usually trapped as a management tool for maintaining game species.

In a statement provided to Newsweek responding to the concerns outlined in the letter, a spokesperson for the FS said: "The Tongass National Forest is working with local communities, regional leaders, our colleagues with the State of Alaska and federal partners to maintain long-term sustainable wolf populations while ensuring rural Alaska residents can continue their subsistence way of life."

"Over the next several months, Alaska Department of Fish & Game and USDA Forest Service biologists will work together to conduct the fall 2019 population estimate and den site investigations. Both agencies will also work with their respective staff and local communities to observe and gather information on wolf populations and behavior. The fall 2019 population estimate will be available in September of this year."

"Once that information is gathered, experts and leaders from the Forest Service and State of Alaska will make a decision consistent the local Management Plan and the goal of managing the population within the objective range. A reduced or closed season is among the options we will consider," the FS said.

The ADF&G also responded to a Newsweek enquiry regarding the high numbers of wolves harvested during the past trapping season, with a spokesperson pointing towards a letter from the agency's director replying to people who have submitted emails raising concerns about the population, referred to as "Unit 2."

"As managers of the state's fish and game resources, we at the Alaska Department of Fish and Game recognize our obligations under the public trust doctrine and our responsibility to current and future generations," ADF&G Director Eddie Grasser wrote in the letter dated to April 9. "Further, Alaska's Constitution mandates that fish and game populations be managed on a sustained yield basis, and direction from the Alaska Board of Game (Board) is to maintain a fall Unit 2 wolf population of 150-200 wolves."

"We agree that the fall 2019 Unit 2 wolf harvest was high and if repeated year after year, would be unsustainable. In fall 2019 harvest regulations changed, and we believe the high harvest resulted from much greater than anticipated trapping effort. Over the last ten years an average of about 15 trappers have reported harvesting wolves in Unit 2, but in 2019 32 trappers reported harvesting wolves."

According to the Grasser, the primary change in harvest regulations in the fall of 2019 was that instead of announcing a pre-season harvest quota, the agency announced a season length.

"The 2018 trapping season was managed under a harvest quota and was open for five weeks (November 15 to December 21.) The 2019 trapping season was open for eight weeks, less than half of the maximum season length allowed in regulation. It is unclear why this change would inspire a doubling in trapper participation," Grasser wrote.

He added that once the new population estimate is ready later this year, ADF&G biologists and leadership will "set fall 2020 harvest opportunity consistent with our constitutional mandate and provisions in the Unit 2 Wolf Management Plan with the goal of maintaining or returning the population to within the objective range. A reduced or closed season is among the options we will consider."

Getting a clear picture of the number of wolves in the region is no easy task, however. While the last official estimate for the wolf population on Prince of Wales Island stands at 170, some locals say that this figure is actually a significant underestimate, partly due to the limitations of the counting techniques used and the difficulty of the terrain.

"The population estimate made by the ADF&G was a mid-range population estimate," Michael Douvillehe, a 71-year-old resident of Prince of Wales island who has years of experience with its wildlife, told Newsweek. "All who attended the pre-season meeting with the department had the opinion that the estimated number was at least 50 percent low; this was borne out by the harvest of 165. It appears that the harvest was between 40 to 50 percent of the real population."

"I can say this with confidence several of the people who live here—including myself—maintain cameras and document wolf pack numbers on several areas of the islands, and are still seeing a viable population within the department's population goal," he said.

According to local journalist Jeff Lund—who grew up on Prince of Wales and now lives in Ketchikan, one island to the east—the wolves in the region can pose a significant problem for people living in the area.

"Deer populations have dwindled while wolf populations have exploded. Deer populations are particularly important for the Natives and locals who rely on deer to eat as a main food source. Even trappers I know don't want them eradicated," Lund told Newsweek. "Residents on Prince of Wales are dependent on subsistence lifestyles to survive. Deer is a staple in the diets of most, if not all residents, and the thought of allowing the wolf population to devastate deer populations makes many locals distrusting of conservation organizations."

Mathew Cross, who lives on Kake—the next island north of Prince of Wales—said that he, like many others in the region, relies on hunting deer and moose to feed himself throughout the year.

"I personally do not trap, but I am very close to those that do," Cross told Newsweek. "Predator management is something that has always been a touchy subject. Wolves are a beautiful, almost mythical creature that have a unique allure to them. No hunter or trapper wants to kill all wolves. We simply want to help keep the wolf numbers in balance so that the deer and moose that we rely on to survive are available to us."

"You see, we that hunt are not cruel and we don't have this desire to see animals die, we just have an intimate relationship with the ecosystem around us. Unfortunately death is at fact of life. It is an unpleasant, sad aspect, but is necessary for life."

This article was updated to include additional information provided by the U.S. Forest Service, Alaska Department of Fish and Game and locals living in the Prince of Wales Island region.