Republican Runners and Riders Gather at the Starting Gate

0515_GOP
An attendee wears a GOP elephant necklace in March 2014 during the California Republican Party's spring convention in Burlingame. Stephen Lam/Reuters

In something of a surprise (given that few Republicans have taken a pass), former U.N. Ambassador John Bolton has declared that he won't run for president, begging the question: Which Michael Bolton song best describes this courtship that won't be?

  1. "A Time for Letting Go"
  2. "I'm Not Ready"
  3. "Nowhere to Run"
  4. "You Don't Want Me Bad Enough"

At least the late Tom Dewey can rest in peace—he's the last GOP presidential nominee to have sported a mustache, as does Bolton. Dewey's last run was in 1948; there hasn't been a presidential nominee with facial hair since then.

Bolton's announcement continues what has amounted to "foreign policy week" for the Republican hopefuls. It included Marco Rubio outlining an approach that at least one conservative writer likened to the Truman Doctrine, Jeb Bush continuing to clarify his 20/20 hindsight answer on the Iraq invasion, plus Chris Christie, Ted Cruz and Rand Paul all piling on Bush.

If that sounds like a lot of bodies in motion...well, it is. About enough to fill a 40-man baseball roster.

Earlier this week, the Republican National Committee launched a straw poll on its website that asked this simple question: "Who would you like to see as the Republican nominee in the 2016 presidential election?"

The choices (brace yourself; it'll take a while to get through this):

  1. Kelly Ayotte
  2. Haley Barbour
  3. John Bolton
  4. Jeb Bush
  5. Herman Cain
  6. Ben Carson
  7. Chris Christie
  8. Ted Cruz
  9. Mitch Daniels
  10. Mark Everson
  11. Carly Fiorina
  12. Newt Gingrich
  13. Lindsey Graham
  14. Nikki Haley
  15. Mike Huckabee
  16. Bobby Jindal
  17. John Kasich
  18. Peter King
  19. Susana Martinez
  20. Sarah Palin
  21. George Pataki
  22. Rand Paul
  23. Ron Paul
  24. Tim Pawlenty
  25. Mike Pence
  26. Rick Perry
  27. Condoleezza Rice
  28. Mitt Romney
  29. Marco Rubio
  30. Brian Sandoval
  31. Rick Santorum
  32. Tim Scott
  33. John Thune
  34. Donald Trump
  35. Scott Walker
  36. Alan West

Two things to note about this list: (a) It's a compilation meant to avoid offense, which explains a lot of folks listed who aren't interested in running; (b) What, no Paul Ryan (or, for that matter, Greg Abbott)?

Meanwhile, there's the question of how the GOP is going to pull off the televised spectacle of a dozen-or-so candidates crowding one debate stage in Cleveland this August for the first gathering. Does the party exclude all candidates polling at 1 percent or less? Or, as some back-in-the-pack candidates would prefer, does it split the field in half and hold not one but two debates over consecutive nights?

There's also the question of format, which The New York Times examines here:

It is not entirely clear who will be in charge of devising or enforcing the debate criteria—that is, if there are criteria. One member of the national committee panel charged with overseeing the debates said its members had discussed ceding the decision entirely to Fox News.

At issue is how to stage a substantive discussion that is fair to viewers and the campaigns. The party has little appetite for a forum so thick with candidates that it allows for not much more than an extended 'lightning round' of questions. One Republican involved in the process said a 90-minute forum with 10 candidates would offer each candidate only four to five minutes, after subtracting commercials and moderator time.

Sounds like there's a good debate awaiting Republicans...in advance of that first Republican debate.

Bill Whalen is a research fellow at the Hoover Institution. This article first appeared on his blog, A Day at the Races.

Uncommon Knowledge

Newsweek is committed to challenging conventional wisdom and finding connections in the search for common ground.

Newsweek is committed to challenging conventional wisdom and finding connections in the search for common ground.

About the writer

Bill Whalen

To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, Click here.

Newsweek cover
  • Newsweek magazine delivered to your door
  • Newsweek Voices: Diverse audio opinions
  • Enjoy ad-free browsing on Newsweek.com
  • Comment on articles
  • Newsweek app updates on-the-go
Newsweek cover
  • Newsweek Voices: Diverse audio opinions
  • Enjoy ad-free browsing on Newsweek.com
  • Comment on articles
  • Newsweek app updates on-the-go